The NBA Player Poll: Unveiling the League's Most Overrated and Underrated Players and Coaches
The Athletic's 2026 NBA Player Poll has once again shed light on the league's most underrated and overrated players, as well as the most impressive and least impressive coaches. The poll, conducted among 161 players, offers a fascinating glimpse into the perceptions and opinions of the NBA's elite.
Most Underrated Player: Derrick White
Derrick White of the Boston Celtics has consistently been a top choice for the most underrated player. With a 3.3% vote share, he tied for the win with the Oklahoma City Thunder's Jalen Williams in 2024 and finished second the previous year. White's versatility and impact on both ends of the court are remarkable. His ability to contribute to winning teams, earn NBA titles, and be named to the All-Defensive Second Team showcases his value. However, he has never been named an All-Star or an All-NBA player, which some players believe is a slight.
Most Overrated Player: Alperen Şengün
Alperen Şengün, the Houston Rockets' star, earned his second All-Star nod this season. His impressive stats of 20.4 points, 8.9 rebounds, and 6.2 assists per game, along with four triple-doubles, have earned him recognition. However, some players believe he is overrated, citing his crying on the court and lack of defensive prowess. Despite the Rockets' sixth-place finish in defensive rating, Şengün's reputation as a strong defender is not universally shared.
Best Coach: Joe Mazzulla
Joe Mazzulla, the Celtics' head coach, has been a standout choice for the most impressive coach. His ability to lead the Celtics to a 56-26 regular-season record, second in the East, and second in offense and fourth in defense, despite the absence of Jayson Tatum, is commendable. Mazzulla's tenacity and ability to fire up his team have earned him respect from players.
Least Impressive Coach: Brian Keefe
Brian Keefe, the Washington Wizards' coach, has been a controversial choice for the least impressive coach. The Wizards finished the season with the league's worst record, 17-65, with losses in 26 of their last 27 games. Keefe's team struggled offensively, and players have expressed frustration with his leadership and the team's performance.
The poll also revealed interesting insights into the league's best defensive player, with Victor Wembanyama receiving the most votes. However, the poll's results are subject to change as the NBA season progresses, and coaches may be replaced or players' reputations may shift.
